Tuesday, November 10, 2015

Some Thoughts about Hunger and a Fat Dentist


Understanding hunger is important to a lot of people in the developed world, because we believe we are too fat. If only we could be less hungry, we would eat less food, and we wouldn't be so fat.
I'm not thinking about Hunger with a capital 'H,' the hunger of people who don't have enough food at all. I have never experienced that kind of hunger, and I pray that I never well.
I'm also not thinking about the hunger one feels on Yom Kippur.
I'm also not thinking about the hunger one feels for emotional reasons, or just the simple pleasure of eating something sweet or salty, a brownie or some potato chips.
I'm thinking of the hunger that well-fed people feel at the hour when they ordinarily eat.
That hunger, as I experience it, is a kind of discomfort, not more acute than, let's say, having tired feet at a museum, and a lot less acute than a bad headache. But it's real discomfort.
That kind of hunger is different from other types of discomfort, because it's so easy to get rid of it. You don't have to take an analgesic. You don't have to sit down and take off your shoes. All you have to do is eat something.
I get very hungry before mealtimes and especially when, for some reason, I am
eating later than usual - much more hungry than a lot of people I know (like my wife).

Years ago, when I attended some meditation retreats, I was taught how to deal with discomfort while meditating. Instead of saying to yourself, "My back really hurts," you're supposed to think, "I have a sensation in my lower back," without classifying it as pain, and thus as something to avert. You're supposed to give the sensation your attention, to locate it, to feel it - and then, as happens in meditation, your mind will wander, you call your attention back to your breathing, and the sensation in your back no longer distracts you.
Can one do the same thing with hunger? It's seven o'clock, say, and you ordinarily eat at seven, but tonight you're going out and you won't be eating till nine. Your abdomen is telling you to put some food inside yourself.
You have several options: you can give in and eat something, you can hold out, not eat, and become grouchy, or you can examine the message your abdomen is sending you: Where is the discomfort situated? How acute is it? What other sensations are connected with it? Usually I eat something.
In our society, while we are constantly being bombarded with advertisements for highly caloric, unhealthy foods, nevertheless being overweight tends to be regarded as a moral failing. When I was a child, my mother routinely referred to our dentist with the almost Homeric epithet of "that fat pig," as in, "I have an appointment with [name withheld, even though my mother and the dentist are long deceased] today, that fat pig."
Fat or not fat, he was a great dentist.

Saturday, October 31, 2015

I Don't/Can't Understand

A train of thought.
After living in Israel for more than forty years, I have come to realize that I will never understand this country. The society is too complex and diverse. The history is too deep and mixed up. People's agendas are strongly conflicted. And the symbolic importance of Israel in our own eyes and in the eyes of other people in the world - friends and enemies, both categories too extreme - not only makes it impossible to stick to facts, it also makes it impossible to figure out what the facts are.

Then I started thinking about the ways a society understands itself, if it's at all permissible to think of societies as entities that can understand or misunderstand. As individuals and as members of a society, we use the stories we tell about ourselves to persuade ourselves that we understand ourselves. Historians, social scientists, journalists, authors, film-makers, religious leaders, politicians, and so on to create and modify these stories. But every story is partial, selective.
This also applies to the stories that individuals tell themselves about themselves, to explain to themselves who they are. At bottom, I think people are as helpless to understand themselves as they are to understand the society and world they live in. We don't know enough, even about ourselves, to understand ourselves.
This thought led me to realize that all understanding is partial. No one can know enough to understand fully even the tiniest thing or event. For what would full understanding be like? To understand a water molecule in my blood, do I have to know how hydrogen was produced in the big bang that purportedly marked the beginning of the universe? Millions of biological processes transpire in our bodies every second. Can I ignore them if I want to understand myself? Only if I think that what goes on in my body has no connection with what goes on in my mind and heart.
Experimental science has moved toward understanding phenomena by keeping every variable but one constant, so as to understand how that variable works. But as soon as you put that variable back into the context of the whole phenomenon, you get stuck in a wilderness of details.
Also, of course, things are constantly in flux.
This line of thought led me to understand [sic!] something I heard years ago about the importance of metonymy - the part for the whole. Think of an ordinary film. In two hours or so, it takes you through a much longer period of time, years, perhaps. It does so by persuading us that the little scenes of life that we see on the screen are representative of much great chunks of experience.
This is true of all our experience of other people and of life. We have a conversation with someone and feel as if we know that person. We spend a week in Paris and feel as if we know the French. We know four or five supposed facts about someone and imagine we know their life history.
It's upsetting to think that all knowledge is partial. We want a story that will explain everything perfectly and leave no loose ends. So, inevitably we will be either deluded or disappointed.

Friday, September 18, 2015

Duty Calls - Do I Have to Listen?

Two things fall together: my reading of Shakespeare and the High Holidays.
Honor is one of the main themes in Shakespeare's plays, especially as the duty a person has to self-image. A noble person is expected, and expects himself, to behave nobly. Honor is worth more than life itself - or at least that is how the ideal is presented in the plays. Betrayal is both of the trust placed in one by others and of the standards to which one holds oneself.
Honor is not a particularly Jewish value, at least as it plays out among the European aristocracy. If you insult a rabbi, he's not going to challenge you to a duel.
But the theme of the High Holidays is not unrelated to the idea of honor: we are deeply aware that we have sinned, we promise to better ourselves, and we ask God for forgiveness. A Jew who takes her identity seriously sets high standards of behavior for herself. Failure to live up to those standards is almost inevitable, but one has the duty of trying.
The sense of duty applies in almost every area of life. One has duties toward one's family, one's friends, one's community, one 's employer, and oneself. The sense of duty is both contractual and emotional, to the letter of the law and to its spirit.
In my work as a translator, I often have no personal connection with my clients. I have never laid eyes on some of them. My obligation to them is strictly professional. Yet I feel a personal obligation to them - to do the best work I can, on time, even to do things that aren't expected of me like checking the spelling of authors' names. I try to live up to what I see as professional standards, and it's always a pleasure to encounter someone else who has that attitude.
* * *
Here's a great example of high professional standards:
Recently Dror Ben-Gur, a musician and saxophone repairman, told me about the Japanese repairman who instructed him in New York. Dror once arrived a few minutes early for a session and found a flute lying on the repairman's table, completely in pieces.
"How are you going to finish putting that together in time?" Dror asked.
"Watch this," said the repairman, and in five minutes he had assembled the flute down to the last screw and spring.
"How did you do that?" asked Dror.
"In Japan," the man replied, "we learn to work in the dark!"
* * *
Some people appear to have no sense of duty, while others suffer because their sense of duty is exaggerated. On Yom Kippur you're really not supposed to say to God, "I did the best I could," but for the sake of sanity, while it's a good idea to aspire to improve, one must be aware of one's limitations and accept them.

Thursday, September 10, 2015

Electronic Shakespeare

When you read on a tablet, you don't feel the heft of the physical book, the feeling that the end is in sight as the stack of unread pages on your right (with an English book) gets smaller, and the bulk of read pages on your left gets bigger. I knew that when I got to The Tempest, I was close to the end, and I was surprised to find out that Timon of Athens, Titus Andronicus, and Troilus and Cressida still awaited me. Unless another play is hiding behind Troilus and Cressida, I'll have read through the complete works in a little while.

Timon of Athens, which I'd never read, turned out to be something like a hybrid of "Nobody Knows You When You're Down and Out" and the Book of Job, and Titus Andronicus (I can't imagine anyone else reading that play unless it was assigned in a course) is as violent and gruesome as some of the movies and TV series I've been avoiding.
Clearly some of Shakespeare's works are of literary interest today only because they were written by the genius who wrote Hamlet and Midsummer Night's Dream. But even in the sub-standard plays there are passages of breathtaking beauty, of course.
Of course?
You try writing a passage of breathtaking beauty like John of Gaunt's praise of England from Richard II, not one of Shakespeare's greatest plays:
This royal throne of kings, this scepter'd isle, This earth of majesty, this seat of Mars, This other Eden, demi-paradise, This fortress built by Nature for herself Against infection and the hand of war, This happy breed of men, this little world, This precious stone set in the silver sea, Which serves it in the office of a wall, Or as a moat defensive to a house, Against the envy of less happier lands, This blessed plot, this earth, this realm, this England, This nurse, this teeming womb of royal kings, Fear'd by their breed and famous by their birth, Renowned for their deeds as far from home, For Christian service and true chivalry, As is the sepulchre in stubborn Jewry, Of the world's ransom, blessed Mary's Son, This land of such dear souls, this dear dear land, Dear for her reputation through the world, Is now leased out, I die pronouncing it, Like to a tenement or pelting farm: England, bound in with the triumphant sea Whose rocky shore beats back the envious siege Of watery Neptune, is now bound in with shame, With inky blots and rotten parchment bonds: That England, that was wont to conquer others, Hath made a shameful conquest of itself.
The project of reading all of Shakespeare offered me a fine demonstration of my ignorance (about British history, for example, and of Elizabethan English) and has left me with a lot of questions, whose answers I might pursue, if I'm not too lazy.
One of these questions involves the connection between dramatic convention and real life. One of the main drivers of plot in Shakespeare's plays is the conceit of love at first sight.
The moment Romeo lays eyes on Juliet, he forgets all other women. The moment Ferdinand spies Miranda (in The Tempest), he knows she's the woman for him. In Midsummer Night's Dream the lovers keep falling in and out of love with each other, on the spot, thanks to magic - perhaps a humorous comment about the dramatic convention.
I don't know the history of this convention. It certainly goes back as far as Jacob and Rachel in the Bible and remains powerful in contemporary fiction, drama, and film. So maybe there's something to it, and it's not just a literary convention.
In general, there is something to almost everything in these plays, meaning that, even though some of their concerns are local and time-bound, Shakespeare manages to present them in a way that enables us to identify with them, five hundred years after he wrote them. 
Perhaps I should be distinguishing between conventions like love at first sight, which he uses to push the action forward - insults to honor, intrigue and manipulation, deceit - and universal human concerns. 
Take Cymbeline, which involves a bet on a woman's chastity, rather offensive to twenty-first century readers. Still, if the spam messages I keep getting, advertisements for services to find out whether my spouse is cheating on me are indicative of anything, the issue of trust in relationships is perennial. 
Needless to say, the themes of ambition, revenge, honor, trust are not peculiar to English society at the end of the sixteenth century. Conventions change, but people have always been people, so I assume (and hope) we'll keep reading and staging Shakespeare.

Wednesday, September 9, 2015

A Hospital Lobby, Flute Practice, Turning my Back on Someone in Need


A week or so ago I found myself sitting in the lobby of a hospital with nothing much to do, waiting for my wife to emerge from a medical examination, so I started scribbling in my diary, something I do only occasionally. 
I used to write lengthy entries in diaries, and I kept them for years, but when our son Asher died, I threw away all my old diaries. I knew I would never reread them, and I didn't want to leave cartons full of banalities for posterity. His death made me feel very unimportant.
The paper in the diary I'm writing in now is hand-made and thick. I bought it in Mumbai. I write with a fountain pen, and it's fun to see the way the ink is absorbed in the paper. I write by hand because I enjoy the act of forming the letters. I get no physical pleasure from typing and seeing the letters pop up on my computer screen.
Since Asher died, I find myself prone to worry about illness and accidents – not to myself so much as to the people I love. But I wasn't worried about the results of my wife's examination. We were focused on the unpleasant preparations and never thought about the possibility that it might reveal some horrible disease (fortunately it didn't).
Recently two vital people we knew, both younger than we are, died of cancer. Our age cohort is thinning out. 
Once I was an optimist.
* * *
In my diary I started writing about the flute I bought at an exorbitant price, an unjustifiable extravagance, perhaps, but I'll try to justify it nonetheless.
How much longer do I have to play flute until I die? Not that many years. I'm sure I'll never be as good a player as I'd like to be, but why not give myself the pleasure of playing on a good instrument while I can still play? Besides, I'm a fairly rich man, though I find it hard to write those words (my mother always thought of us as “middle class”). I could afford to buy a professional-level instrument without affecting our standard of living at all – so I did it. Anyway, the flute will always be of value, and my heirs can sell it.
I wasn't really sure when I went to the music store in Tel Aviv that I would upgrade my flute, but the moment I played two or three notes on the instruments the salesman showed me, I could feel the difference between my decent instrument and the excellent ones I was trying out.
I know the flute is not going to sit in a corner untouched. I've become obsessive about practicing. Every day I go through a methodical routine to improve my tone and articulation, and this slow and careful work has carried over to my saxophone playing. I hear more.
* * *
I have been exposed to two different approaches to practice. My flute teacher, Raanan Eylon, is a stickler for detail and aims at control of the instrument. He has decades of experience and a coherent method for attaining that control. A couple of years ago I heard a fantastic young guitarist say, “practice the same thing every day” – a corroboration of Raanan's approach. If you practice the same thing every day, you can monitor your progress.
However, the late Arnie Lawrence, my musical guru, if I ever had one, said, “Don't practice! Play!” The approach of Raul Jaurenga, a brilliant tango musician to whom I was exposed this summer, is similar to Arnie's. He said you should start out by falling in love with your instrument, spending time every day just exploring the sounds you can make.
The point is to combine the two approaches. Arnie was a master of his instrument, and Raul plays the bandoneon with incredible skill. Raanan, with all his emphasis on sound production, aims at enabling his students to play a melody communicatively. When I play something badly he says: “I don't understand.” Technique and feeling must go hand in hand. Feeling must provide the drive for acquiring technique, and the acquisition of technique enables the expression of feeling.
* * *
As I was writing this I got a phone call that makes all this thinking about music feel terrifically self-indulgent (as if reading about the refugee crisis in Europe or the asylum seekers here in Israel weren't enough to make flute practice a bit like feeding brioche to the poor). Two distant relatives of mine have gotten themselves in a bind, and I've become involved in their problem even though, objectively (if there is such a thing), they are not my responsibility.
I am not prepared to do what a more charitable person would do, which is to take them into my home, lend them money, and care for them until they can get onto their feet. I would admire someone who did that, but I have to admit to myself that I'm not the kind of person I would admire.
I feel guilty and angry at the people who put me in a situation where I feel guilty.

Tuesday, August 25, 2015

Interesting, Important, and Authentic (1)

Nothing is absolutely interesting. A lot of what I care about, for example, is of little or no interest to most people, and a lot of what many people in the world care about (at least insofar as the media pays attention to it) is of little or no interest to me - like who wins a golf or tennis tournament, or whether a certain movie star is having an affair with another movie star.
Since I am a translator and editor, I am very interested in correct and effective word choice, issues of fidelity to the author's intention, sentence structure, and a great many other technical matters that I wouldn't necessarily care very much about if it weren't my job to care about them. I certainly don't expect anyone in a casual conversation to respond to these topics without a yawn.
Similarly, as an amateur musician interested in improving my improvisational skills, I am concerned with harmony, rhythm, phrasing, originality, coherence, and so on, with specific application to playing a melody over a series of chords. There is no reason why anyone who isn't trying to improvise in music to have the slightest interest in these things. You can enjoy listening to jazz without knowing how Sonny Rollins handled a half-diminished chord.
Yet good writers and movie-makers do manage to make technical details interesting even to people who ordinarily don't care about them. How?
**
Long ago, when I was a student of literature, I never considered the issue of why some writing is boring and other writing is fascinating. All the works we were reading in the courses that I took were more or less universally acknowledged to be important, hence interesting. And the better teachers managed to bring us into the works and make them interesting for most of us, because they themselves were interested in them. That, perhaps, is they key to arousing interest in an audience of readers, listeners, or viewers. One manages to make oneself interesting, and, consequently, what interests one will also interest others. Though, obviously, some of the students in general literature courses in college were only taking them because they were required to, and the only interest they developed in the books they read was related to passing the course. The charisma of the professors, if there was such, was lost on them.
I majored in French literature because I thought it was important, not just because I was good in French and enjoyed reading. I was interested in literature because I was convinced that it was important.
But what did I mean by important? In what way is literature important? How could I convince an economics or engineering major, for example, that he or she ought to care about Shakespeare? For that matter, how could they convince me that it was more important to master economics or electrical engineering than to understand King Lear?
Is "importance" just as relative as "interest"?

Monday, August 24, 2015

Klezmer and the Unity of the Jewish People (?)

We enjoyed the Klezmer festival in Safed because the music was, in general, great, the crowds were relaxed and friendly, and almost every variety of Jewish Israeli was represented. Because admission to the concerts was free, lots of people who couldn't ordinarily afford to go to concerts came to Safed to hear the music. The streets were lined with booths selling fast food, jewelry, clothes, and assorted stuff (I bought a digital wristwatch for only twenty sheqels!).
Between pieces, many of the Israeli musicians offered religious inspiration. After all, Safed was the home of Kabbalah five hundred years ago, and a lot of the townspeople are following personal, mystical agendas, floating through the streets of the old city a few centimeters off the ground.
Speaking for myself, I could have done without earnest sermons about the potency of the month of Elul for penitence, the coming of the messiah, and miracles that came through prayer. Music itself is enough of a miracle.
One of the sermonizers, the guitarist in the middle of the top picture, gave a heartfelt plea for Jewish unity. If only we were all unified, respecting differences but still together, we could surmount all obstacles.
His talk made me realize how much anxiety people like him feel because of the deep and significant conflicts among segments of the Israeli Jewish population (forget about the gaps between the Jewish Israelis and the Muslim, Christian, and Druze Arabs, as well as the black African asylum seekers, and the non-Jewish immigrants from the former USSR).
What kind of unity was he talking about?
I deeply disapprove of the behavior and opinions of quite a few of my fellow Jewish citizens of Israel, and I know they disapprove of me. For example, I regard the Jewish settlers in Hebron as criminals. Expressing that opinion publicly, on Facebook, for example, is an invitation to vicious attacks, even death threats (since almost no one reads this blog, I don't think I have anything to fear on that account). How can there be unity between people who disapprove so categorically of one another?
Anyway, Jewish unity is a myth. There never was Jewish unity, and there never will be. We have a culture of controversy and confrontation, both within the tradition and between traditionalists and modernists. Perhaps because we were always differentiated from the gentiles around us, we are very sensitive to differences within our community: differences in ethnicity, in levels of Jewish observance, in social class, in political orientation, and in level of education.
Shlomo Bar, an extremely Moroccan musician, appeared with Tsemed Re'im, an extremely Ashkenazic pair of singers who have been performing together for more than forty years. They sang beautifully and made a lot of stupid jokes about Moroccans and Ashkenazim, but they also showed great respect for each other's music and made a show of the traditional Jewishness they all drew upon. They, too, preached Jewish unity, as if admiration for both Andalusian and Moldovan Jewish music would solve all of Israel's problems. Their message was a feel good message, not overtly religious or political: we can all get along, and our culture is big enough for both Oriental and Klezmer music.
But anxiety about lack of unity has a strong political dimension. That anxiety is a characteristic of right wing politics, certainly in Israel, and probably elsewhere as well, and comfort with diversity and difference of opinion is characteristic of the left. The left challenges the status quo, the right maintains it.
One reason why the left can't get its message across to the very people who are suffering most because of right wing policies is the failure to address this anxiety. The left is seen as negative, controversial, divisive. Zahava Galon (the head of the leftwing Zionist party, Meretz) doesn't make anyone feel good.